Lit for the first time in September of 1852, the original structure lasted only until 1858, when it was demolished and a new, well built structure went up. In 1972, the tower light was replaced by an automated beacon mounted on a steel skeletal tower.

The Lighthouse and Fog Signal Building stood vacant after closing, until 1985 when a local group organized the Grand Traverse Lighthouse Foundation with a goal of preserving the historic buildings and creating an interesting and educational "living lighthouse" for the public to enjoy. After two years of renovation, the Lighthouse Foundation reopened the station as a museum on Memorial Day in 1987.

Spoontiques is a highly desired line of collectible lighthouse, popular with collectors. This is due to the attention to detail and historical accuracy where ever possible.